County Of Middlesex v. Exxon Mobil Corporation

Can’t hire good help these days. With this particular case, I can just envision a scene at the Krovatin Nau LLC New Jersey law firm back on September 30th, where a hurriedly-arranged meeting has the top lawyers saying they needed to get a lawsuit filed right quick in order to take advantage of the news about the Supreme Court examining Boulder v Suncor. One of the top partners points to a hapless intern who appears to be barely out of high school and says, “You! Grab a copy of our Hoboken v Exxon filing and change the plaintiffs to ‘Middlesex’ and reword it to reflect that, then use this login account to file it at the courthouse by the end of the day!”

Regarding this 44-page newest of all “ExxonKnew” lawsuits filing, the folks at Energy in Depth explain in their October 1, 2026 article how maladroitly-handled it is – the lawsuit document itself sure looks like it is missing 100+ pages. But I’ll show in this post how, despite not appearing to contain any direct accusation about ‘industry-led disinformation campaigns,’ it does indeed refer in the vaguest way, dumbest way to three out of the four main accusation elements that are in most of the other “ExxonKnew” lawsuits across the country.

I can’t remember if it was Steve Milloy or James Taylor – both lawyers – who made the joke at a Heartland Institute climate conference that lawyers themselves don’t read other lawyers’ lawsuits, they just read the introductions and the conclusions and hope that what’s in the middle matches both. I don’t even go that far, I just do word searches for phrases / names out of my checklist to see if a filing regurgitates any elements of the false narrative that skeptic climate scientists were paid by fossil fuel company executives to spread disinformation.

Within Middlesex v. Exxon, despite how Energy in Depth said it grabbed items straight out of the September 2020 Hoboken filing …. I didn’t see any of the accusation elements in there. How odd.

So where are those in Middlesex? You just have to scratch a little deeper. Being this filing is a copy of Hoboken, the particular repeated words are the clue.

PDF file / print page 21:  c) Defendants, individually, through trade associations like API, and through front groups like ICE and the GCC, coordinated campaigns to deceive the public about the known and foreseeable threats their fossil fuels posed to the climate in order to mislead consumers and turn public opinion against actions to restrict their extraction, production, and sale of fossil fuels.

Fine. Sounds really sinister, worthy of suing Exxon and all the other fossil fuel companies. That exact sentence is identically repeated as “item c” twice more in the Middlesex filing, on PDF file / print page 27 and PDF file / print page 32. The first in the trio comes under the just-prior page 20’s paragraph #47 about Exxon et al.’s ‘conduct.’ The second repetition is under the page-prior 26’s paragraph #62 about what the plaintiffs are suing over; the third is the page-prior 31’s paragraph #81 about what Exxon et al.’s reckless conduct was.

Hoboken v Exxon contains the absolutely identical “item c” repeated identically three times, first on PDF file / print page 118 onto 119, and then again on PDF file / print page 126, and the third time on PDF file / print page 132, where the first of the repetitions concerned Hoboken’s paragraph 291 claim about Exxon et al.’s ‘conduct’; paragraph #309 seemingly repeating what Exxon et al.’s reckless conduct was; and the third is the paragraph #326 which again lists what Exxon et al.’s reckless conduct was.

Basically, this confirms what the Energy in Depth was saying about the Middlesex filing copying content straight out of Hoboken.

But here’s the wacko problem with the Middlesex filing: it does identify “API” as the filing’s defendant American Petroleum Institute, but absolutely, positively nowhere within it does it ever say what the “ICE” acronym stands for. They also skip saying what/who “the GCC” is, but that’s a different story.

Not being a lawyer and not playing one on TV, I’d still think plaintiffs would be never be able to proceed with a lawsuit if they hurled an accusation such as “Defendants coordinated campaigns to deceive the public individually through front groups like ICE” without saying exactly who or what that is. But notice how Hoboken is 146 pages in length and Middlesex is only 44.

As I already showed up above, and in my dissection of Hoboken back in September 2020, without knowing there’d be a future need to show it again, that filing spelled out what “the ICE” was. But for good measure here, I’ll add some more details:

In their attempt to spin the “ICE” and “the GCC” as industry-run sinister operations tasked with deceiving the public …

… the handlers of the Hoboken filing managed to make two errors straight away in connection with the “ICE” name – one small and one bigger.

A lell-tale indicator throughout the years for anyone not knowing what they are talking about regarding the actual short-lived ICE public relations campaign is their substitution of the word “on” within the spelled-out acronym. The official ICE campaign was the “Information Council for the Environment.” The inept original promulgators who got real media traction going about the false accusation about the “reposition global warming” memo, Ozone Action and Ross Gelbspan, made that “on” substitution error.

The bigger error in that above Hoboken claim is that “Defendants played a significant role” in the ICE PR campaign. No, the defendants are all oil producers and the API defendant is an oil industry trade group. The ICE campaign was run by the Western Fuels Association, a non-profit co-operative handling transport of coal from mines to electric generating plants. Oil companies have no interest in electricity-generating operations.

Of course, making matters worse is how – just like so many other “ExxonKnew” lawsuits that refer to the ICE campaign as ‘evidence’ that the fossil fuel industry ran ‘disinformation campaigns,’ Hoboken regurgitated the false accusation about the “reposition global warming” memo being a directive for the campaign participants to spew lies.The memo was an unsolicited proposal sent by the Edison Electric Institute to the Western Fuels Association, which completely rejected the proposal. Unlike so many of the other lawsuits which tie more than one ‘newspaper advertorial’ to the ICE PR campaign, Hoboken chose to only repeat the accusation about the “Chicken Little” advertorial. … which was never published anywhere.

As for the “Global Climate Coalition,” that group was of so little consequence and influence that – when grilled about it in a PBS Frontline hit piece against the oil industry – (the late) skeptic climate scientist Dr Patrick Michaels had difficulty remembering who they were. But at my July 2022 blog post about hundreds if not thousands of “Greenpeace Investigations” document scans disappearing off the internet, I showed how the GCC was a particular fixation of John Passacantando, former head of Greenpeace USA / Ozone Action. That latter group being the first to provide lasting, ongoing media traction to the above-noted “reposition global warming” memos. As I said within my blog post about the disappeared Greenpeace scans, I never paid much attention to the accusations about the GCC because a review of their docs showed “there’s no there there.” But the mere fact that the original Hoboken filing railed about the GCC for four pages, starting at their PDF file page 57, may actually be an indicator (hint) of a far deeper problem with not only the Hoboken (and potentially hugely 100+ page-revised future Middlesex version 2 filing), it may indicate a hidden problem across the board in the “ExxonKnew” lawsuits which mention the GCC in any way. Hold the thought about the definition of “psychological projection” as it may relate to how Passacantando and the people immediately surrounding his efforts imply guilt by association throughout their effots to impugn the credibility of skeptic climate scientists.

Meanwhile, the Krovatin Nau LLC law firm handlers of Middlesex / Hoboken do spell out the acronym of API, but offer no ‘smoking gun evidence’ in their little weeks-old 44 page filing for claims that API sought to deceive the public. Their 2020 Hoboken was as predictable as could be on dutifully regurgitating the standard accusation about the [meritless, never implemented] “victory will be achieved” memo being a deliberately planned public deception effort on API’s part. Who is the source for the memo? The Inside Climate News’ PDF file scan – which as I’ve shown in prior blog posts for other similar ‘citation cascade’ instances – is an exact duplicate, right down to the same photocopy dust spots, of the scans at the Climate Files website, operated by Kert Davies. Davies’ Climate Files scans are an exact duplicate, right down to the same photocopy dust spots, of his 2013 PDF file upload when he was still working at Greenpeace USA.

While never directly mentioned in Middlesex but definitely tied to Hoboken, there you have three of the four standard accusation elements found in the Sher Edling boilerplate copy filings. Absent in the Middlesex filing is any obvious shared words / tie-ins to Krovatin Nau’s Hoboken filing about ‘$1.2 million being paid to skeptic climate scientist Dr Willie Soon.’ Who’s the source for that in Hoboken? The Union of Concerned Scientists. Who’s the source for the UCS? A New York Times 2015 article. Who’s the source for the NYT? Greenpeace /Kert Davies. Another ‘citation cascade,’ seemingly done to hide the original source. Dr Soon is more than happy to explain how the accusation against him is totally false.

See why I used the word “hint” two paragraphs above for my screencapture link to Hoboken‘s citation source for the GCC? In my blog post list about the apparent plagiarism problem within the “ExxonKnew” lawsuits, my entry for the Krovatin Nau LLC-filed lawsuit suggested that readers can compare Hoboken‘s accusation about the “reposition global warming” memo to Sher Edling’s Hawaii v Sunoco page for the same accusation.

Did the Krovatin Nau LLC law firm simply find all their accusation material all by themselves to insert into their first Hoboken filing? Did that firm lazily lift their accusation material right out of Sher Edling filings? Or is the four pages of material about the GCC within Hoboken an indicator that something else is going on behind the scenes across the board in the “ExxonKnew” lawsuits?

Shouldn’t a reporter actually read what’s in this lawsuit and wonder why the three-peat acronyms for specific disinformation groups aren’t spelled out, and what ‘evidence’ there is to support the claims that disinformation campaigns existed? Shouldn’t objective reporters across the country lament that yet another one of these “ExxonKnew” lawsuits has been filed when essentially every one of them dating back to 2017 could be consolidated under a single filing titled “John Passacantando, Kert Davies, et al. [ dba Greenpeace USA née Ozone Action / Our Next Economy / CIC ] v. Exxon & any other applicable energy companies we can think of”?

Just askin.’